Affirmative Case -Data Collection & Analysis

1. Definition of the term: (from dictionary/legal citations/operational definitions through Aff. plan)

n “Euthanasia” refers to _________________________________________________________

  ______________________________________________________________________________

2. STOCK issues that constitute a Prima Facie case (SHITS-D) :

A. Status Quo(現況):

n 法律層面 (Legal Status) 

n 醫療層面 (Medical Standpoint) 政府主管機關 

n 科學研究/理論 (Theoretical Basis)

n 社會組織/民間機構 (NGOs/NPOs)

  1.

        2.

n 國際現況(他國做法/立場/律法) (International Practices)

     1.

     2.

     3.

n 社會新聞/實際案例 (News/Cases)

1. (Date/Place/Description)

      2.

      3.

 B. Harm(現況造成的問題):

n   To ____________:

n   To ____________:

n   To ____________:

C. Significance(問題的顯著影響層面)- Argue the harm is significant:

n   Qualitative (violation of a society’s core value)

n   Quantitative (widespread problem) 

D. Inherency (問題源自於現況體制/無法解決)

E. Topicality (Every discussed aspect related to the topic?) 

________________________________________________________________________________

3. Plan (planks): Feasibility + workability

n   Mandates(法律層面)

   1.

     2.

n   Administration (政府機關/執行單位/執法機關) 

n   Enforcement

1. 執行方式:

2. 對象: 

3. Criminal penalty:

n   Funding ($ from?)

   1. costs: 

   2. funds: